NCAA President Charlie Baker Announces Legal Filing in Ohio Federal Court

The NCAA has filed a federal lawsuit against Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine challenging an executive order that allows Ohio colleges and universities to disregard certain NCAA eligibility restrictions.
The lawsuit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio at the direction of the NCAA Board of Governors and Division I Board of Directors, seeks declaratory and injunctive relief.
The dispute concerns an executive order addressing NCAA eligibility rules that limit athletes’ opportunities to compete beyond their established eligibility periods. The NCAA contends that the order could permit Ohio institutions to field athletes who would otherwise be ineligible under association rules.
The NCAA raises three principal legal arguments. First, it alleges that the executive order violates the Commerce Clause of the U.S. Constitution by providing Ohio institutions with a competitive advantage over schools in other states.
Second, the association argues that the order infringes its First Amendment rights by interfering with its ability to establish and enforce membership rules.
Third, the NCAA contends that DeWine exceeded his authority under Ohio law by permitting institutions to disregard eligibility requirements they agreed to follow as NCAA members.
The association also maintains that allowing athletes who exhausted their eligibility during the 2025-26 academic year to return for another season could affect roster opportunities for other student-athletes.
The lawsuit asks the federal court to determine whether the executive order can lawfully affect the NCAA’s enforcement of its eligibility regulations.
Separately, the NCAA addressed ongoing litigation in Borovicanin, an Ohio case involving challenges to NCAA eligibility restrictions.
According to the NCAA, the Ohio Supreme Court recently stayed the issuance of a mandate from the Ohio First District Court of Appeals but did not explicitly reinstate a trial court injunction that had favored the athletes.
The NCAA interprets that procedural action as leaving the trial court’s injunction stayed, meaning the plaintiffs have not been declared immediately eligible to compete. That interpretation remains part of the ongoing legal dispute.
The association said it expects to respond to questions from the Ohio Supreme Court concerning the procedural status of the case.
The federal lawsuit and the Borovicanin proceedings reflect continuing disagreements over the authority of state governments, courts and the NCAA to determine eligibility requirements for college athletes.
